How does Master ASL! compare?
CHARACTERISTICS |
MASTER
|
LEARNING ASL |
SIGNING NATURALLY |
|
STANDARDS
|
|||
| Meets national foreign language standards / 5 C's |
|
||
| Meets rigorous state foreign language standards |
|
||
|
PHILOSOPHY
|
|||
| Bilingual / bicultural philosophy |
|
||
| Functional-notional philosophy |
|
||
| Total immersion philosophy |
|
||
| Teacher-focused |
|
||
| Student-focused |
|
||
|
STUDENT-FRIENDLY
|
|||
| Ethnically diverse sign models that appeal to high school / college students |
|
||
| Commitment to diversity and multicultural differences |
|
||
| Vocabulary index, with full conceptual meanings |
|
|
|
| Addresses up-to-date cultural and technological issues in the Deaf World |
|
||
| Topics follow sequence of natural conversation |
|
||
| Color illustrations designed to elicit language use |
|
||
| Step-by-step approach of skills presented in a logical manner |
|
||
| that encourages language use |
|
||
| Addresses problems and weaknesses often seen in ASL students |
|
||
| Filmed dialogues are illustrated in student book |
|
||
|
TEACHER-FRIENDLY
|
|||
| Unit objectives |
|
|
|
| Skill benchmarks |
|
||
| Sign variations from around the United States and Canada |
|
||
| Assessment guides for each unit |
|
||
| Must adapt and expand curriculum to suit student needs |
|
|
|
|
ALL-IN-ONE TEXTBOOK
|
|||
| Language |
|
|
|
| Grammar / structure exercises |
|
|
|
| Receptive emphasis |
|
|
|
| Expressive emphasis |
|
||
| Classroom exercises |
|
|
|
| Homework exercises, including differentials for multi-skilled classrooms |
|
||
| Full-color artwork by leading Deaf artists |
|
||
| Deaf history |
|
|
|
| Social analysis of Deaf & Hearing worlds Culture |
|
||
|
USER-FRIENDLY
|
|||
| Clear student objectives for each unit |
|
||
| Hardcover, full-color textbook |
|
||
| Clear instruction on ASL grammar / structure |
|
||
| Extensive fingerspelling, number, and glossing exercises |
|
||
| Focus on native-like expressive rhythm |
|
||
| Emphasis on expressive skills |
|
||
| Emphasis on receptive skills |
|
|
|
| Conversational skills limited to specific functions and situations |
|
||
|
DVD / VIDEOTAPE
|
|||
| DVD / videotape materials feature high school and college-aged signers |
|
||
| DVD / videotape features ASL grammar / structure lessons with examples |
|
||
| DVD / videotape features Deaf culture lessons with examples |
|
|
|
| Narratives on a variety of topics aligned with each unit |
|
||
| Dialogues on a variety of topics in each unit |
|
||
| Interactive menus and scene selection means easy access |
|
|
|




